“As human beings, we are endowed with freedom of choice, and we cannot shuffle off our responsibility upon the shoulders of God or nature. We must shoulder it ourselves. It is our responsibility.”
Arnold J. Toynbee
On the other hand, the California Chief Justice made no response at all to my equally polite bureaucratic letter which pointed out that:
- Judicial trainers made disparaging remarks about the veracity of abused women and children.
- Training on domestic violence and child sexual abuse was not done by experts.
- Court-appointed evaluators did not have guidance on how to consistently follow the complex laws and rules of court. Our template that provided such guidance had been rejected.
- Oversight of appointees was minimal because appeals were financially out of reach for parents.
- Counties with recommending mediation resulted in more complaints to us.
- AB 939 had created a non-stipulated case management system which, in the words of one presiding judge, “Causes due process to go out the window.” They were attempting to make courts into social services agencies, by providing mediation and services to clients, not justice to litigants. This was the result of the Elkins Family Law Task Force report, which instead of proposing legal remedies for more due process, the remedies were for less due process.
I suggested specific domestic violence courts as a possible remedy, and that mediation is not appropriate for criminal acts.
Nothing.
California Chief Justice Ronald George announced he was retiring which came as a surprise to us. During his term that began in 1991, the Administrative Office of the Court (AOC) had bloated from 100 to 1000 staff members. It was later shown by the Bureau of State Audits that the top Judicial Council hierarchy was paid equally bloated salaries.
The Chief Justice had begun a plan for a computer system that would unify the state’s myriad of systems into one a decade before. Meanwhile, the judiciary had been under scrutiny by the CA Assembly Oversight and Accountability Committee. A whistleblower law was passed, but there were still gaps in protecting judiciary staff from retaliation. As we had learned, over 50 staff had been fired for blowing the whistle on misconduct regarding illegal hiring of non-licensed contractors.
This was not our issue, but we learned there was a committee tasked with oversight and accountability. This was a steep learning curve.
The highly touted judiciary computer system, the California Court Case Management System (CCMS) would have replaced 70 different legacy systems and united court technology statewide. By 2009, a group of 500 judges had formed a splinter group called the Alliance of California Judges. Founding Judge Loren McMasters had raised “principled objections” to the CCMS, and a tug of war ensued between central and local control of courts.
The project was so riddled with cronyism, poor planning and poor management, as was pointed out by the Bureau of State Audits report in February, that it was finally scrapped after wasting $500 million of our taxpayer dollars.
(The California Court Case Management System) was finally scrapped after wasting $500 million of our taxpayer dollars.
The judicial computer boondoggle had created such massive waste, fraud and abuse that the Legislature clipped their wings by reducing their budget. This ultimately had unintended negative consequences for litigants. Many courts cut services, including court reporters, which led to the inability to file appeals or make effective complaints. Longtime administrator of the CA court system (AOC) William Vickery resigned.
My personal favorite part of the scandal was that at the exact same time, I was working as part of a team to roll out a statewide new system in my day job. I had a bulldog bureaucratic persistence and had lobbied for the new system for a decade, stubbornly, politely taking the idea to management, sleuthing out the benefits in other comparable organizations, tenaciously meeting with anyone who would sit still and listen.
I thought after retiring, I’d lost the game, but a few years later, a colleague called. “How’d you like to come back and help us roll out the new system?” We played by the rules with good management and oversight. In 2011 our new system rolled out early and under budget.
Kathleen was invited to the White House to plead our mothers cause on the national level again. None of the initiatives and programs thus far focused on divorce and custody in family courts. They were broader sweeps. We needed a narrow focus on not placing abused children at risk in custody decisions.
The new Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye was sworn in on January 3, 2011. She was a mother and had been on the Judicial Council’s Domestic Violence Task Force (different from the Elkins Family Law Task Force which dealt with court procedures such as giving in person testimony.)
She was from a child-centered Filipino culture. At the same time, Kamala Harris became the first woman, first African American, first Indian American Attorney General of California. She was sworn in by the new Chief Justice.
We dared to feel hope.
Then there was another blow. Family Code section 3183 went into effect, codifying the exact opposite of what we had asked for in our comments to Elkins Family Law Task Force. It allowed court mediators, who were called “Child Custody Recommending Counselors CCRCs)” to make recommendations for custody and visitation as long as the parents and attorneys saw the recommendations first. Judges usually followed their recommendations.
Was this an improvement? I honestly didn’t know. Judges were often clueless, powerful and unpredictable. But we were finding the mediators could be just as unpredictable and were often biased towards powerful, well-dressed charming fathers versus frantic domestic violence victims trying desperately to protect their children.
Meanwhile, California State Senator Deborah Ortiz (ret) wrote a strong letter to both State Assemblyman Feuer and Senator Mark Leno on the Legislative Judiciary Committees about the misfiring of her decade-old bill to properly investigate cases of child sexual abuse.
California State Senator Deborah Ortiz (ret) wrote a strong letter …. about the misfiring of her decade-old bill to properly investigate cases of child sexual abuse.
DEBORAH ORTIZ
(Personal contact information deleted)
November 22, 2010
The Honorable Mark Leno
California State Capitol Building
Sacramento, CA 95814
Re: SB 1716 – Child Custody Investigator Training Standards
Dear Senator Leno,
I am writing regarding SB 1716, a bill enacted in January 2001, to request your assistance in developing clarifying legislation.
Background
It was my privilege to author SB 1716 that amended and created Family Code sections 3110.5 through 3118 and subsequent California Rules of Court 5.220 and 5.225 and that set standards for licensure, training in the nature of child sexual abuse, and investigation protocols for all court-connected and private custody evaluators who are court-appointed investigators under Family Code section 3110. The intent of this legislation was to ensure safety for children whose custody is being decided in the Family Court.
Since the enactment of this legislation, there has been continued serious concern from the child protection community that the amount and quality of training in child sexual abuse identification, the personnel being trained and appointed, the quality and uniformity of the reports, the protocol for report submission, and the regulation of payment are not consistent with what was required and intended by SB 1716.
Child Sexual Abuse Training,
Concerns have been brought to my attention that, in some of the 40 hour training required by Rule of Court 5.225(d) to implement Family Code section 3110.5(b)(2), training time spent on child sexual abuse is quite brief, the curriculum lacks uniformity, trainers are inexperienced in investigation or prosecution of child sexual abuse, and court employees are not being trained, as was intended by SB 1716.
- I support legislation to provide for a set number of hours of training (optimally 24 of the required base 40 hours of training and six of each eight-hour annual update training) that is based on peer-reviewed, scientific research and is exclusively on child sexual abuse.
- I also support legislation designating the use of a standard model curriculum (such as the National Judicial Education Program’s Adjudicating Allegations of Child Sexual Abuse When Custody is in Dispute: A Model Judicial Curriculum, produced in collaboration with the American Bar Association Center on Children and the Law) to be team-taught by at least two different instructors with experience in investigating and prosecuting child sexual abuse.
- It is important to clarify that investigator training and protocol in Family Code section 3110.5 are intended to apply to all supervising and associate counselors and mediators described in Family Code section 3164 and to court-connected and private child custody investigators, to ensure that uniform training exists for all court employees and appointees. Although it would be inappropriate for mediators, whose role is to assist parents to come to an agreement on parenting issues, to conduct investigations pursuant to Family Code sections 3110.5 through 3118, mediators need a minimum working knowledge of the dynamics of child abuse as well as the dynamics of domestic violence.
Investigator Reports
The intent of SB 1716 was to provide the court with uniform, accurate investigative reports by well-trained, neutral court investigators, to help the court make decisions that ensure child safety whenever allegations of abuse arise. It has been brought to my attention that private expert witnesses are being appointed who are paid directly by the parties, often do not follow the protocol required by Family Code section 3118, submit reports in a variety of formats prior to stipulation by parties, and include parenting recommendations in the investigative reports.
It was never the intention of this section to have court appointed private expert witnesses under Evidence Code section 730 complete investigations pursuant to Family Code sections 3111 and 3118. It was not the intent of SB 1716 for the court to order the parties to pay investigators directly, to read the report before review and stipulation by the parties, or to have investigators make parenting recommendations. I support legislation that would clarify the legislative intent and ensure that the intent of SB 1716 is implemented.
- To ensure statewide uniformity and ensure compliance with the protocol specified by Family Code section 3118, it will be necessary to develop a comprehensive report form to be completed by investigators statewide, with recommendations limited to ensuring child safety.
- The investigators should specify on the report that they have met each and every required training topic listed in Rules of Court 5.225 and 5.230 and will provide all certificates of training completion upon request by a party, a party’s attorney, or the court.
- The parties and their attorneys would sign the report form indicating that they have reviewed the report and made any needed factual corrections prior to stipulation.
- Family Code section 3111(c) was written to ensure that the investigator’s report is not received or read by the court unless the parties stipulate to its admission into evidence. If the parties do not stipulate to the report, the court should hold a properly noticed evidentiary hearing at which the investigator is present for examination by the parties or their attorneys prior to the report being read by the court.
- Family Code section 3112 was written to ensure that investigators who are employed or appointed by the court are paid by the court. Only under certain conditions is the court repaid by the parties.
- 6. The terms “investigator” and “evaluator” are used synonymously throughout Family Code sections 3110-3118. To ensure consistency and provide clarity for parties and their attorneys, the single term “investigator” should be utilized throughout, pursuant to Family Code section 3110.
I look forward to your assistance and please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions. Thank you for your leadership and hard work to protect our children in California.
Sincerely, Deborah Ortiz, Senator (Ret.)