Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 9: Forward Progress, Then Backwards

“Divorce lawyers stoke anger and fear in their clients, knowing that as long as the conflicts remain unresolved the revenue stream will keep flowing.”

Craig Ferguson

Senator Ortiz (ret) was not pleased that the intent of her bill SB 1716 had been thwarted. We had worked with her directly on the issues and language and her letter was pitch perfect. I don’t know if the Legislators answered her letter, but we felt better knowing how clear the judicial requirement were.

We waited patiently for change to occur on the ground. There was no change.

I kept writing letters, including to Yolo County Assemblywoman Mariko Yamada, US Senator Dianne Feinstein, President Obama and Kathleen Sebelius of the US HHS.  We made appointments. U. S. Senator Barbara Boxer introduced the Violence Against Children Act, which apparently died in committee. We did not know about it, so did not turn out in support even though we were there at the time and could have done something to help. We needed to develop better communications with the staff members.

The Eighth Battered Mothers Custody Conference was held in Albany NY. That year the conference emphasized the importance of uniting diverse groups and individuals to reform custody courts.  Karen and I were not able to go, so protective mother Kathy Lee presented a workshop called Advocacy is Showing Up, inviting people to our next Washington DC demonstration in February 2011

Mothers of Lost Children arrived in Washington DC on Sunday February 13 and held a vigil and demonstration at the White House.  Mildred Mohammad, beltway sniper John Mohammad’s former wife, spoke out. She said she was told by federal agents that he was in fact trying to kill her after she won custody of their two children in 2001. He had run away with the children in 1999, and after he was found, began working on the perfect crime to make it look like she was just one of many victims, to deflect attention from him.

Mildred Mohammad

On Valentine’s Day 2011, we held a press conference in front of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 200 Independence Ave. SW. We protested the enormous expenditure, waste, fraud and abuse of tax dollars that were paying fatherhood program advocates to go into prisons to help felons connect with their children.

Something happened.

A lone reporter showed up. Then the police arrived.

We were summarily ushered off the premises because we taxpayers had been peacefully standing on a wide sidewalk area in front of the building. It was federal property. We moved along slowly, with as much dignity as we could muster, marching up the hill toward the Congressional buildings, our banners held high.

Mildred Mohammed marched with us, up Independence Avenue, across First Street, and over to the Senate Hart Building on Constitution Avenue, where we met with California Senator Feinstein’s staff. Protective mother Shannon testified to staff that she had applied for help from the Department of Health and Human Services’ federally funded non-custodial parent program and was told she could not receive services because she was a woman.

No one gasped. They looked mildly interested, but not enough for action.

We delivered packets of information to every Senate office. We were getting the lay of the land and decided to first approach the Senate, primarily because there were only 100 Senate offices in three huge buildings lined up along Constitution Avenue. It was easier than going to the House, with their 435 offices lined up along Independence Avenue on the other side of the wide mall. 

I was shocked when the Director of Public Affairs of HHS Jesse Moore called the day after our press conference and connected me with Vicki Turetsky. She was the Commissioner of Child Support Enforcement and Access and Visitation grants. We talked on February 18. She explained the funding began with Congress and flowed down to states that decide where the funds go, likely courts, domestic violence agencies, child welfare services (CWS) and supervised visitation programs. Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) has no jurisdiction.

She explained that Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood (HMRF) was a separate program for education and employment so non-custodial parents (84% fathers) would get jobs and support their children with the $150 million grant funding.

I told her that non-custodial mothers were turned away from the program. She asked what could be done. I suggested domestic violence courts, a template for a multidisciplinary team to complete for their investigation, and Federal oversight of the fatherhood programs.

I was not prepared but managed to hold my own.

The opposition was way ahead of us. They were employed inside the buildings that we were demonstrating in front of.  I found out the Fatherhood Initiative was under Temporary Aid to Needy Families (TANF) 45 CFR part 260. That very year, the game had been upped.

Congress and the President authorized $500 million in Department of Health and Human Services, Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fathers (DHHS HMRF) grants, with the larger portion for responsible fatherhood initiatives, and less toward marriage.  That was a shift from the 2001-2009 Bush administration in which marriage received $100 million and fatherhood $5  0 million. These grants went all over the US, with 16 programs in California.

There was also a www.fatherhood.gov website. No girls allowed.

On the local level, Yolo County Family Justice Center (FJC) held a kickoff of a new program that would in theory bring all relevant entities that work with domestic violence into a single hub, a “one stop shop.”

San Diego attorney Casey Gwinn who had pioneered the idea of Family Justice Centers, was there. He and I talked about the family court, which he said was terrible and the judges were often not supportive of FJCs.

San Diego attorney Casey Gwinn

Neither Senator Lois Wolk nor Assemblywoman Mariko Yamado were there. Yolo County Presiding Judge Dave Roseberg had been invited to this event, but declined, saying it was a conflict of interest, even though Presiding Judge Ronald Adrine in Cleveland was the lead in their Family Justice Center.   The FJC never fully get off the ground, although various agencies did begin working better together.

Garland Waller made another powerful documentary No Way Out But One in 2011 about Holly Collins’ flight from the United States with her beaten and injured children. Holly managed to get to the Netherlands where they were given asylum and protection from her former husband who had fractured her son’s skull, then received custody.

Holly Collins and her children

After the children were grown, she returned to the United States. Attorney Alan Rosenfield brokered a plea deal with the Hennepin County MN court that she could plead guilty to contempt of court and receive community service. Holly gladly agreed. She said she had nothing but contempt for the court that placed her children with their vicious abuser.

On March 2-8, 2011 the San Francisco Weekly published Peter Jamison’s outstanding California Family Courts Helping Pedophiles, Batterer Get Child Custody. The article described a case in Santa Clara County that began two years after the Karen Winner Report excoriated Judge James Stewart and his coterie of appointees who harmed children.

Psychologist Leslie Packard evaluated the family and suggested the mother was paranoid for believing her daughter’s account of molestation by the father. The child’s own attorney Miki Minzer also disbelieved his young client, who later reported years of abuse to the police. Her father then pled no contest and is serving a 23-year sentence.

Judge Stewart finally retired after that case.

Jamison wrote, “In the place of the traditional fact-finding apparatus that operates daily in criminal and civil courtrooms — dueling lawyers, and jurors charged with determining the facts of a case from available evidence — family court substitutes a cadre of individuals who make decisions in concert. Foremost is the judge.”

And no one wants to be a bottom-of-the-judicial-barrel family court judge, according to Oakland attorney Kim Robinson (except Peter McBrien in Sacramento who loved his work so much he came back as a court employed commissioner after retiring as an elected judge.) Peter Jamison described the firing of Emily Gallup, a Stanford-educated court mediator in Nevada County for daring to review parents’ criminal histories. 

Emily Gallup

He covered Richard Gardner MD who created Parental Alienation Syndrome to discredit sex-abuse allegations before stabbing himself to death with a steak knife in 2003.

He described UC San Diego research biologist Joyce Murphy’s case against Henry “Bud” Parson who also ended up in prison after his arrest for sexually abusing other little girls in 2008. 

He wrote, “From the moment she (Judge Deann Salcido) arrived in family court as a new judge, she says, she was advised by veterans of the system to disbelieve accusations of child or spousal abuse arising in divorces. ‘I was basically told to be suspect of anyone claiming abuse,’ she says. ‘I had senior judges telling me, ‘Be suspect. The dad probably has a new girlfriend, and the mom’s upset.’ 

The concept of parental alienation, she says, arose in private discussions ‘all the time’ among court officials who espoused it. Salcido says, ‘In the end, it did turn out that Joyce was right. She was right to be crying, and hysterical, because no one would believe her. I signed a court order handing a kid over to someone who turned out to be a pedophile.’”

He quoted family law attorney Seth Goldstein and Professor Geraldine Stahly who agreed there needs to be a different method of investigation of facts by multi-disciplinary teams for cases of abuse in family court, rather than opinions of paid court-appointees.

Nothing changed in the family court.

It was business as usual.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.