Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 3: Persistence

“It does not matter how slowly you go, as long as you do not stop.”

Confucius

On November 20, Steve Burdo, Kathleen Russell, Barbara Kaufmann and I met with Bethany Westfall from California Senator Bill Monning’s office, Benjamin Palmer from Senator Hann ah Beth Jackson’s office, Heather Resetarits from Senator Bob Wieckowski’s office and Barry Steinhart from Senator Mark Leno’s office. They were all receptive. They all understood.  It was so different. We no longer had to begin from scratch, trying to explain the inexplicable.

We no longer had to begin from scratch, trying to explain the inexplicable.

_________________________________

We attended the Judicial Council Advisory Committee meeting on Access and Fairness/Self-Represented Litigants on November 24. I talked about child safety and how batterers and molesters were getting custody, with no chance for appeals and no court reporters. Racial inequality was rampant. 70% of self-represented litigants were people of color. 

We talked to the attorneys about needing Judicial Performance Evaluations, focus groups or hearings, domestic violence courts, Court Appointed Special Advocates (CASA) for children in family court, restraining orders for children, and of course, a form to implement Family Code 3118.  They too smiled politely.

We got to know some of the staff attorneys who were knowledgeable and concerned and helped us navigate the bureaucratic maze.

On the federal level, law professor Joan Meier, federal analyst Leora Rosen and I continued to work on refining the proposed Congressional Resolution. Staff member Blair Bjellos spent an hour on the phone talking with me about it. She said she would ask her boss Congressman Ted Poe to author it and explained we needed the Judiciary Committee’s approval. It was great news.

I finished the first draft of a Domestic Violence Fact Sheet to match our Child Sexual Abuse Fact Sheet. Attorneys Barbara and Kim, protective mother Yupa, Kathleen and I met Assemblyman Marc Levine’s staff member Mark. 

We met with June Clark at the Governor’s office who had worked for the Judicial Council in the criminal division and was shocked at our information. 

Self-represented domestic violence litigants were getting crushed by their batterers who had expensive attorneys, as their children were whisked away to be reinjured and killed. With no record of hearing, there was no way to complain or appeal.

How could the Legislature or the Court tolerate such imbalance, such injustice? I kept doggedly writing letters.

To our surprise, the Judicial Council’s Administrative Director Martin Hoshino answered with a substantial letter on December 29, 2014. They realized that parents without attorneys were at a disadvantage. He sent information on meetings, task forces and reports. I looked online and found the Judicial Council had made efforts:

Mr. Hoshino also explained that there was a Sargent Shriver Civil Counsel Pilot Program that provided free counsel  for low-income persons, including custody cases. Counties could decide which group of disadvantaged litigants they wanted to help and most chose litigants in landlord/tenant disputes. 

Children still being re-injured and killed in custody cases. My heart broke again. They were small sacrifices, little bodies offered up to the mammon of the stone-faced, glacial judicial and legislative process.

boy looking sad

Even my eternal optimism had been strained over the past decade and a half, but I refused to lose hope. The wheels turned slowly and this was at least some forward movement. Maybe the arc of the moral universe was bending towards justice, although agonizing slowly.

The Office of Violence Against Women (OVW) developed grants to encourage arrests and enforcement of protective orders, with close judicial scrutiny of offender behavior. That was a good beginning. Maybe it would trickle down to family court cases.

Back in California, the California Bureau of State Audits (BSA) 2013 report on the Administrative Office of the Courts (AOC) mess was succinctly titled Judicial Branch Procurement: Semiannual Reports to the Legislature Are of Limited Usefulness, Information Systems Have Weak Controls, and Certain Improvements in Procurement Practices Are Needed (2013‑302 & 2013‑303).

On January 7, 2015, the BSA issued a Fact Sheet on their next audit of funds administered by Administrative Office of the Courts (AOC). It was painfully fun to read

The dry title was Because of Questionable Fiscal and Operational Decisions, the Judicial Council and the Administrative Office of the Courts Have Not Maximized the Funds Available for the Courts (2014-107)  The salient points were:

  • “While courtrooms have had to close or reduce their hours and dismiss thousands of employees, the AOC continued to offer its employees excessive salaries and generous benefits and made other costly decisions.”
  • The salaries of 88 AOC employees are higher than those of the executive branch’s highest paid executives and for 22, their salaries exceed comparable executive branch salaries by more than $1 million annually.
  • The AOC provided its staff with certain benefits that exceeded those in the executive branch and amounted to $5.4 million over a four-year period.
  • Maintaining three work locations – San Francisco, Sacramento and Burbank – is costly and inefficient. The AOC could save over $5 million each year by consolidating offices in Sacramento where the property lease rates are lower.
  • The AOC spent $13.5 million on 55 contractors during fiscal year 2013-2014. We estimate that the AOC could have saved about $7 million per year if it had used state employees in comparable positions.
  • It has not justified its decision to maintain a fleet of at least 66 owned or leased vehicles.”

I was alternately overcome by laughter and tears. We just couldn’t make that stuff up. The 1000 AOC staff were far more handsomely paid than we had ever imagined. The bow-tied attorney Richard Fine who had been jailed after pointing out that judges were double-dipping from both county and state funds was being royally validated.  The new Chief Justice, who had just begun her job the year before, had a lot to clean up.

stick figure angrily sweeping up comments

This entertaining scandal came on top of the $500 million California Case Management System (CCMS) Judicial Council computer boondoggle that was terminated as unworkable back in April 2012. By August that year, the Judicial Council had begun restructuring the AOC, which kind of dropped out as a named entity. I wondered if staff still earned more than the executive branch’s highest paid executives.

Not surprisingly, the Legislature reduced the Judiciary’s budget.

The Judiciary promptly retaliated by firing court reporters and closing courtroom doors.

On January 22, 35 or 40 of us went to the Judicial Council meeting, which was held in Sacramento that time. The mothers continued to speak eloquently, beautifully. I went to the Capitol afterwards and met Heather Resetarits from Senator Bob Wieckowski’s office. Wonderfully, he wanted to take a bill to create a template to implement Family Code section 3118. SB 594 was the first tangible step towards a form. It seemed so easy.  Little did we realize how hard that was going to be.

The Commission on the Status of Women and Girls was resuscitated after a short hiatus, but without our allies.  Protective grandmother Helen and protective mother Cindy worked with the Commission in San Diego, but they were no longer interested in family court after their brief defunding, reorganization and refunding. We wondered why.

On February 19, thirty people in red t-shirts, including attorney Kim Robinson, protective mothers Karen, Sarina, Brook, Roberta, Michele, and I descended on the Judicial Council again.  We weren’t gagged, and 17 of us spoke that time. 

Senator Hannah Beth Jackson was sworn in as a member of the California Judicial Council. She was at the same time the Chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee in the state Legislature. I kept wondering if Legislators should be sitting members of the Judicial Council. It didn’t just seem right. Was it even legal or ethical? It did not pass the sniff test.

This time, Kim, Kathleen, Steve and I met with Senator Wieckowski, who had developed language for the template bill that covered both private and public court recommenders. Barbara and I made a fact sheet. I put together a draft form, which the Judicial Council staff attorney said was too long and complex. At least they were engaged in the process.

On February 24, Kathleen, Kim and I put on our red t shirts and walked in late to a meeting of the Judicial Council Commission on the Future of California’s Courts Task Force in a large sparsely filled auditorium. The public comment time abruptly ended. The room went silent.  They quickly brought the meeting to a close before we could speak. We cornered the Chair, Justice Carol Corrigan afterwards in the hall. She was quite pleasant and talked with us for a while.

However, the future of California courts did not seem to include child safety, as far as we could discern.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.