Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 20: Thought Reform

“When the (Korean War) POWs returned to the United States, their thinking soon returned to normal, contrary to the popular image of “brainwashing.’”

R. J. Lifton

In 2008, another reunification “family camp” program  Overcoming Barriers was founded by Matthew Sullivan, Robin Deutsch and Peggy Ward, all PhD level psychologists. It was incorporated as a 501c3 nonprofit in Massachusetts in 2011.  The mission is “to support a family systems approach to children resisting or rejecting a parent in post separation families.” 

The idea of bonding children with parents they dislike or fear, in any other world, could be considered “enforced trauma bonding.”  The 15-year-old Marin County workshop concept, now trademarked as Building Family Bridges, had spread.

These programs came complete with court orders switching custody to the disliked parent and cutting off all contact with the preferred, trusted parent, with the threat of jail for non-compliance. They also involved at times, a chilling squadron of burly adults in a “transport team” snatching sleeping children from their beds in the night or at the courthouse and transporting them by cars and planes to re-education camps consisting of motel rooms or remote ranches. The children are not allowed to leave.

After a period of being nose-to-nose with the disliked parent, the child then would be placed in the custody of the disliked parent. A later Washington Post Magazine articleThey were taken from their mom to rebond with their dad. It didn’t go well. by Cara Tabachnick exposed the Family Bridges thought reform program, and how now adult children felt about it.  The reporter found that family reunification programs were mandated in 27% of Canadian family court cases when alienation was alleged, with a likely higher prevalence in the United States. 

The reporter found that family reunification programs were mandated in 27% of Canadian family court cases when alienation was alleged

Doctors Sullivan, Deutsch and Ward seem to be vying for the Authoritarian Doctors award, right up there with Randy Rand and Ed Oklan.  The whole situation sounded eerily familiar to those of us who paid attention to post-WWII attempts to change minds and reeducate through forced kidnapping and imprisonment in China and other countries.  The optics were not great.

Overcoming Barriers closed its program after an outside evaluation could not prove its efficacy. Family Bridges was still in business, along with other offshoots. The situation was later addressed in the Violence Against Women Act reauthorization.

In a counter-effort to expose criminal child pornography, in 2008 the Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force Program (ICAC) created a program to support law enforcement investigations of online child exploitations. The system, used by over 4,500 law enforcement agencies, monitors 5.5 million IP addresses of suspects daily.

We wondered why ICAC was not monitoring children ordered to live with their identified parental rapists. Many of the children reported being filmed and shown pornography by their deviant fathers. Maybe we just hadn’t sent information to cybertips?

Or did it have something to do with the fact that the tips may go to National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC), a group that had hunted down mothers who ran with their abused children for decades, at three times the rate of pursuing fathers? We imagined that those reports would likely go into a special round file.

We started a recall of Judge Peter McBrien. It was a steep learning curve and a Quixotic quest.

On March 4, 2008 the United Nations hosted a presentation titled Economic Costs of Women and Children Abuse about child sexual and ritual abuse. I spoke as part of a panel with Eileen King, Lynn Crook, and others. It was put together by medical anthropologist Dana Rafael Ph.D. who hosted a luncheon afterward.

medical anthropologist Dana Rafael Ph.D.

There was a woman at the luncheon who had also graduated from Smith College about the same time I had. She, a professor at an Ivy League college and I, a survivor of extreme abuse, looked at each other silently for quite a while. Without words, just with our eyes, we had a conversation on how childhood adversity changes the trajectory of lives.

We tried, and failed, to block AB 1877 (Adams) to prohibit disclosing a custody evaluation report  And yes, the Judicial Council was required to create a form to implement the bill. The irony must have been delicious for the opposition. Meanwhile, AB 1822 (Beall) to prohibit spousal support to a spouse who was convicted of child sexual abuse died in the Judiciary Committee.

We tried not to feel outgunned.

The Fourteenth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness conference began on April 11, 2008 at the Sierra Health Foundation in Sacramento with Innovative Treatment: A Paradigm Shift with psychiatrist Charles Whitfield M.D., Randy Noblitt, Ph.D., Pam Perskins Noblitt and Wanda Karriker PhD who spoke about early trauma events that underlie adult symptoms. The panel speakers were introduced by Michael Cunningham, Chief Deputy Director of the CA Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs and Steve Mayberg MD Director of the CA Department of Mental Health.  Inviting those dignitaries led to counties sending providers.

Again, we educated county mental health providers, but the likelihood of them reverting to their former training and worldview when they got back to their offices was way too high. They were stuck on the biological model of “mental illness,” not acknowledging that this was “mental injury” caused by early trauma. They kept stubbornly not listening.  The next day’s event was titled  Incest, the Ultimate Betrayal at the Veteran’s Memorial Center in Davis.  Wanda Karriker presented her research on the Extreme Abuse Survey.  Actress Jessica Hendra who played Dejar in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and daughter of comedian Tony Hendra, talked about her own family incest secrets as described in her book How to Cook Your Daughter.

Actress Jessica Hendra

The Courageous Kids spoke. Attorney Seth Goldstein led a discussion on whether incest victims were any safer now that the incest exception was gone. Alison Arngrim and comedian Betsy Salkind came from PROTECT.  We had music by Karie Hillary. Author Carolyn Leahman received an award. She and Jessica had a book signing.

Education was fine, but I couldn’t help brooding. How could we have saved Dr. Amy Castillo’s three children, Anthony 6, Austin 4, and Athena 2, when their father Mark Anthony Castillo drowned them in a Baltimore hotel bathtub that very month, methodically using a stopwatch? After he threatened to kill the children the year before, Maryland Circuit Court Judge Joseph Dugan denied a permanent protective order, leaving them helpless prey.

On the East Coast, Executive Vice President of Leadership Council on Child Abuse and Interpersonal Violence Joyanna Silberg PhD released a press release on September 22, 2008 on their conservative  estimate of the number of children per year ordered into unsupervised contact with physically or sexually abusive parents following divorce (not including separated or non-married parents.)

The answer was 58,500. Every year.  Using the most conservative numbers.  Dr. Silberg stated this was over twice the annual rate of childhood cancer.

Number of children affected by divorce each year1,000,000
Number of families with allegations of child abuse/severe domestic violence (13%)x .13
Total cases= 130,000
When investigated, percentage of cases found/suspected to be valid (43-73%)x .60
Total validated cases  = 78,000
Percentage of children left unprotected (56-90%)x .75
Estimate of US children left in unprotected case of an abuser after divorce  = 58,500

Dr. Silberg stated this was over twice the annual rate of childhood cancer.

We knew from the 1997 Adverse Childhood Experiences study that childhood adversity led to illness, including cancer, and early death. I wondered sadly how many of the court-endangered children would grow up to develop cancer or die early.

The fathers’ rights proponents had done their job well. They had shifted the balance and put women and children last. The fathers we were encountering were proud of their abuse. I wondered what else they were concocting in their chat rooms and meet-up sports bars. 

A September 2008 Government Accountability Office (GAO) audit of the TANF Healthy Marriage Promotion and Responsible Fatherhood programs had found it was not in compliance with the law. That came as no surprise to us. The fathers we knew flaunted the law, along with morality, at every turn.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.