Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 10: Seismic Shifts

“It takes two to speak the truth: one to speak, and another to hear.”

Henry David Thoreau

On March 22, 2011, NCADV Director Rita Smith and DV LEAP Director invited us to present at a Protective Parents Roundtable Discussion at George Washington University Law School in Washington DC.  For the first time ever, the government paid for our trip.

We briefed Judge Susan Carbon, Director of the Office on Violence Against Women (OVW); Lynn Rosenthal, White House Advisor on Violence Against Women and Bryan Samuels, Commissioner of the HHS Administration on Children, Youth and Families. 

Survivors of family court abuses, seven mothers and one teenager spoke and gave recommendations for solutions. In the afternoon there was an expert panel with Rita Smith, Joan Meier, Joan Zorza, Barry Goldstein, Camille Cooper, Eileen King, Kathleen Russell, Karen and me. We discussed the Problem and the Solutions.  Recommendations included:

  • Creating a financial incentive for specialized domestic violence courts using a multidisciplinary team for fact finding, and mandate courts err on the side of child physical and sexual safety.
  • Authorizing a federal undercover investigation into potential collusion, corruption, misuse of federal funds.
  • Cutting funding for fatherhood programs that were being used to reunify even felons in prison with their children without regard for their safety.
  • Disconnecting child support from parenting time to reduce perverse financial incentives.
  • Developing a national data collection for cases where children are placed with abusers.
  • Replacing friendly parent laws (parents who are friendly with each other are more likely to be seen with favor by the court) with child safety laws.
  • Ensuring a standard curriculum is used to train judges and court officials.
  • Requiring attorneys for minors to advocate for their clients.
  • Mandating that all court hearings be videotaped and tapes provided to litigants at cost.
  • Creating an ongoing Grand Jury process to oversee cases of children placed at risk.
  • Creating legislation to reduce judicial immunity if court officials break the law.

This briefing led to a variety of OVW grants which, for California, led to a domestic violence court in Solano County. Sadly, their first domestic violence court judge turned out to be overtly partial to male batterers, so the local activists had to force him out of that position.

At the state level, we supported SB 557 (Kehoe) to authorize multi-agency, multidisciplinary family justice centers in San Diego, Anaheim, Alameda and Solano Counties. To our great relief, it passed.

woman in blue coat smiling

We also supported SB 326 (Yee) giving litigants timely access to their court records. That did not go as well. Not only did the bill die in the Appropriations Committee, but its author Senator Yee was later convicted of felony racketeering for money laundering, public corruption and bribery in a gun running scheme.  If we were reading this story today about events the 1920’s, they would be considered “colorful.”

Our Seventeenth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness conference, Trauma Model Therapy for Child Sexual Abuse was held in April 2011 at the Davis Senior Center. About 100 people came.  Andrea did a great job of putting on the event which was co-sponsored by IVAT and provided continuing education units for psychologists.

Our keynote speaker was Colin Ross MD, director of the Colin Ross Institute formed in 1995 in Texas. 

He trained us on his successful programs with patients who have multiple diagnoses. He did a great job of dissembling the diagnoses silos of diagnoses. They all stemmed from the same origin, wounded children who had gone into hiding in the adult psyche.

(Multiple diagnoses) all stemmed from the same origin, wounded children who had gone into hiding in the adult psyche.

This was not new information to me, but it was particularly well said. He explained that trauma survivors, especially sexual abuse survivors, often suffer from depression, anxiety, dissociation, somatization, borderline personality, amnesia, self-injury, substance abuse, eating disorders, fibromyalgia and other symptoms of their abuse, sometimes all at the same time.

His program was tested and effective across the board for all these conditions.

He discussed the long-term effects of child abuse, including attachment to perpetrators, a trauma model of borderline personality disorder, a dissociative subtype of schizophrenia, the connection of childhood trauma with eating disorders, and how to choose a trauma therapist.

Dr. Ross exemplified everything that a trauma therapist should be. He had written seven books on trauma and dissociation and dozens of articles. My personal favorite is still The CIA Doctors: Human Rights Violations by American Psychiatrists, second only to R. J. Lifton’s  The Nazi Doctors: Medical Killing and the Psychology of Genocide.   

In the afternoon, educator, musician, entertainer Rhonda Begos spoke as an advocate for children and women’s rights. We even had a sign language interpreter. 

Two enlightening books on the scourge of ritual abuse were published that year. 

This secretive abuse was not so secret anymore.

On May 8, 2011, the second Mother’s Day March was held at the White House, led by protective mothers Kathy Lee and Shannon. They were delighted at the turnout and candlelight vigil.  They went to DHHS and the Senate. The next day there was a parallel Mother’s Day March in Sacramento with 50 people wearing white. Protective mother Sue organized it, with a speak out by Presley and Carolyn from Center for Judicial Excellence.

Linda Marie Sachs hand-delivered her 40-page appeal, called a Petition for Certiorari, which was accepted by the Supreme Court for review. Her children had been removed from her in Florida by Judge Shawn Briese in 2007.  His ruling had been reversed and the case remanded back to him, but he refused to vacate his order, leaving Linda Marie on supervised visits.

Linda Marie Sachs

I continued the letter writing campaign, writing to Joshua DuBois, director of the White House Office of Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships about the Fatherhood Initiative being the catalyst for battering and molesting men getting custody. I wrote to Dr. Phil who did a hatchet job on a girl who reported abuse, then recanted.

There were inspirations along the way. A significant event took place in 2011 that focused an international lens on the United States. Over a  decade before, in June 1999, Jessica Lenehan Gonzales’ three daughters Leslie (7). Katheryn (8) and Rebecca (10) were abducted by their father and killed either before or during a police bullet storm. Protective mother Jessica took her Colorado case all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court in 2005. The Supreme Court said Jessica had no Constitutional right to police enforcement of her restraining order. 

Not one to back down, Jessica asked her attorney, “So, who’s the boss of the Supreme Court?” She was one small brave battered mother who stood tall and refused to give up. Her attorney Carrie Bettinger Lopez and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) took her case to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR).

IACHR ultimately issued  recommendations on July 21, 2011 The US was, indeed, committing human rights violations against mothers and children.

IACHR found that the failure of the police to protect these children was a form of “discrimination of the American Declaration.” The state did not duly investigate the complaints or the circumstances of her children’s deaths, and law enforcement officers were not held accountable. 

IACHR found that the failure of the police to protect these children was a form of “discrimination of the American Declaration.”

IACHR recommended specifically that the US “adopt multifaceted legislation at the federal and state levels, or reform existing legislation, including protection measures for children in the context of domestic violence” based on Jessica’s case. The U.S. was encouraged to conduct a serious, impartial, exhaustive investigation into systemic failures, and legislate precautionary measures to protect women and children like Jessica and her girls.

It was another Pyrrhic victory.

The U.S. government made a few attempts at remedies, but the Office of Violence Against Women’s pilot project of four jurisdictions was not followed by strong legislation to remedy the overarching problem. Every effort seemed to be too late, too broad and failed to focus on the corrupt practices going on at ground zero, the family courtroom.

Children continue to be taken from safe mothers by family courts and placed in the custody of batterers and molesters who then re-injured and sometimes killed them.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.