“Throughout history, it has been the inaction of those who could have acted, the indifference of those who should have known better, the silence of the voice of justice when it mattered most, that has made it possible for evil to triumph.”
Haile Selassie
Our travel schedule in 2012 was just short of ridiculous. We flew back across the country to Albany NY for the Ninth Battered Mothers Custody Conference on January 6-8, 2012. It was titled Is What We’re Doing Working? We were on a panel with Barry Goldstein, Joan Zorza, Eileen King and Kathleen Russell. We updated our activism talking points to frame the issue as a civil and human rights problem.
Therapist Karin Huffer’s panel was aptly titled Is What We Are Doing Working? Yes…But Not Fast Enough. We also had an organizing panel, gathering advocates together. I gave the child custody template to Gabriella Davis, legal policy advisor from the Battered Women’s Justice Project who said she would test it with friendly Ohio judges.



On February 29, 2012, Director and Chief Counsel Victoria Henley of the California Commission on Judicial Performance wrote a surprisingly strongly-worded letter to Governor Jerry Brown, the new Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye, the Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg and Speaker of the Assembly John Perez regarding the fact that courts were terminating court reporters to reduce costs, and not replacing them with another means of recording procedures.
“As a result there are fewer records of proceedings,” she said. “California, ordinarily a leader in the administration of justice, is falling behind other states in which the public is protected and the administration of justice is preserved by recording all court procedures.”
In December 2011, only half the complaints had a record. The CJP could not properly do their job of oversight without a record.
She went on, succinctly. “The use of private court reporters hired by one party in litigation causes numerous concerns, including the questionable admissibility of the transcript as an official court record and access to justice for those of limited means. The problem should be addressed before the administration of justice in California is further compromised, in the commission’s case as well as in judicial proceedings.” Exactly.
“The use of private court reporters hired by one party in litigation causes numerous concerns”
Two weeks later the Metropolitan News published an unsettling article titled CJP Voices Concern Over Court Reporter Cutbacks, citing court reporter layoffs as a threat to investigations of judicial misconduct due to lack of verbatim record of proceedings. At the time, we did not realize how compromising these cutbacks would prove to be. It soon became apparent as the ability to appeal bad family court decisions disappeared into a bottomless pit.
A Congressional briefing titledCourt Practices and Programs to Improve Justice and Safety for Children and Families: The Outcomes for Children of Abuse was heldby Congressman Bobby Scott and the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges (NCJFCJ) on March 2. We were not able to go to that briefing which primarily focused on juvenile court and foster care issues.
However, Judge Karen Hawze from Washington DC described the Amy Castillo child custody case in detail. She pointed out that the family court did not protect those children through supervised visitation in that divorce case. Subsequently, their father Mark Castillo drowned Anthony (6), Austin (4) and Athena (2) in a hotel bathroom in 2008.
California Juvenile Court Judge Michael Nash spoke on juvenile court. Previously, he had opened Los Angeles juvenile courts and found it worked fine in the sunshine, without secrecy.

We were thrilled that child safety and custody was being discussed in Congress. The NCJFCJ had even created a series of Judges Bench Cards, including one titled A Judicial Guide to Child Safety in Custody Cases. Bench cards provide judges with useful questions and to help them make decisions based on the emerging scientific findings. I wondered if bench officers had ever actually used the bench cards. The real problem was lack of interest. And hubris.
My growing concern was that there was a darker reason for certain judges to ignore child sexual abuse. Could some have an unhealthy interest in children, like California Judge Ronald Kline who was found guilty of possession of child pornography?
Other judicial officers had been accused and convicted, or committed suicide after accusations of similar crimes against children, including
- California juvenile court judicial officer Daniel Horton,
- Utah Judge Kevin Christensen,
- South Carolina judge James B. Gosnell Jr. ,
- Wisconsin Children’s Court Judge Brett Blomme,
- Oregon Judge John Mann, Maryland Judge Jonathan Newell,
- Florida Judge Jeffrey Ashton,
- New Jersey Judge Stephen W. Thompson ,
- Alabama Judge Roy Moore,
- California Judge Jeffrey Wiatt.
Judges clearly were not immune from this type of perversion.