Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 9: Something Happened

“You must never be fearful about what you are doing when it is right”.

Martin Luther King, Jr.

January 2016 was a good month for California activists.  Executive Director of Family Violence Appellate Project (FVAP) Erin Smith sent an 11-page letter to the Judicial Council’s Commission on the Future of California’s Court System, asking the Commission to address the critical need for transcripts, a fundamental due process need.

.  Executive Director of Family Violence Appellate Project (FVAP) Erin Smith

The Bureau of State Audits issued yet another audit report titled The State Bar of California: It Has Not Consistently Protected the Public Through Its Attorney Discipline Process and Lacks Accountability.  Elaine Howle and her Bureau of State Audits team were doing their part sleuthing out corruption and deficits.

In 2010, the backlog of complaints against California attorneys reached 5,174 cases while the State Bar spent $76.6 million in 2012 on a building.

Reforms followed.

The most important reform was described by former State Bar chair Michael Colantuono.  “The State Bar of California has been both the State agency which regulates the practice of law and the professional association for attorneys since 1927. To focus on its core regulatory public protection mission, the State Bar is now transferring that second role, advocacy for lawyers and their clients – to the newly formed California Lawyers Association.”

The agency that disciplines lawyers was bifurcated from the cozy lawyer club in 2018.  This was one of the reforms Kathleen Russell from Center for Judicial Excellence had proposed.  Our fear was that the good old boys would simply migrate from club to agency.  We hoped it was more than a cosmetic fix and would lead to more ethical behavior. 

That month, Maria Palazzolo and I visited the new Solano Court Integrated Domestic Violence Court with high expectations. The first disappointment was that they only accepted cases when a parent had been convicted of domestic violence. They must have realized that few batterers were convicted, so were considering expanding to include cases with restraining orders to increase participation. 

The case we watched went moderately well.  Judge Ichikawa ordered the batterer to treatment for substance abuse which I regarded as a primary problem. Children should not have to grow up with a parent with active substance abuse.

However, we noticed that the domestic violence court judge seemed much more compassionate toward the batterer than toward his victims.

However, we noticed that the domestic violence court judge seemed much more compassionate toward the batterer than toward his victim. 

We met with Judge Ichikawa in person. I asked directly if he spoke with children to get their preferences for custody and visitation. He replied flatly, “No.” Not ever.

He seemed entirely undisturbed by the fact that Family Code 3042(a) ensures “children who are of sufficient age and capacity to reason so as to form an intelligent preference as to custody or visitation, the court shall consider, and give due weight to, the wishes of the child in making an order granting or modifying custody or visitation.”  And that at age 14 they had the right to talk to the judge, if they wanted.

We were stunned.  After all our hard work on AB 1050, it was utterly ignored by this state-of-the-art domestic violence court. 

Was having a dedicated domestic violence court an improvement over generalist courtrooms?  It depended on the judge. The Sacramento court watch program had found that 14% of cases were for domestic violence and 7% were for child abuse within the general family court system.

The benefit of a domestic violence court is that court watchers could keep an eye on a single courtroom.

Solano County was also creating a Family Justice Center, co-locating the Multi-Disciplinary Interview Team, medical examining room, Victim Witness coordinator, counseling center, and domestic violence center near the courthouse, and were planning for more partners. We were impressed.

The next month, the Solano Partnership Against Violence invited Karen and me to their monthly roundtable which included representatives from the Legislature and Congress. Protective mother Jaclyn was sitting at the other end of the long table from us. She listened intently, then validated everything we said. It was happening right there in Solano County, despite their Integrated Domestic Violence Court, court reporters in every court by special statute, and a Family Justice Center.

gavel with money in the background

Local activism worked well. Their court watch method consisted of sitting in court, and when a judge ordered a child into the arms of an abuser, they gently approached the weeping mother (they were always mothers) and gave her their card, thus building their numbers one by one until they had a small local army. 

We were working with a case in Yolo County where a protective mother fled to France and then to the Netherlands. Even though neither parent lived in the county and the Yolo County case was only to determine parentage, the DA’s office was spending huge amounts of time and money pursuing her.

We had to point out that absurdity before things settled down. We were stretched too thin to follow the Solano County method, but Dave Greenwald was focusing his criminal court watch on family court.

We kept going to the Judicial Council monthly meetings. At one, we suggested that having evaluators and mediators give their reports and custody recommendations to judges before parents could correct the reports and before sworn testimony in hearings was a massive due process problem.

I quoted from a transcript: “The Court has already made findings that we are going to reunify these 3 children with their father, whether the abuse happened or not.” It was written by one of the Judicial Council members, who was glaring right at me the whole time with that rare-bug-I’d-like-to-squash look.

“The Court has already made findings that we are going to reunify these 3 children with their father, whether the abuse happened or not.”

The Stahly research showed that mediators were a major problem, often recommending children live with their abusers. It was a shock to parents to realized that they were not in mediation at all, and that the mediator was in the role of a mini judge, since the court usually adopted their recommendation. It was a bait and switch.

We wrote to the Judicial Council’s Commission on the Future of California Courts in February in strong opposition to their idea of calling them “child custody recommending counselors (CCRCs).” CCRCs tended to be slightly less off- base in their recommendations than private evaluators, but this was undermining due process. We suggested instead:

  • Confidential mediation.
  • Evidentiary hearings.
  • Record of all hearings.
  • Assurance of child safety.
  • No-cost administrative review.
  • Custody disposition surveys.
  • Investigation of cases where children were placed at risk.
  • Judicial Performance Evaluations.

I met an appellate court Justice there who asked for information about our concerns about recommending mediators. He kindly forwarded the information to Justice Corrigan, the chair of the Futures Commission.  That seemed to have some impact in their final 2017 Report which recommended more self-help resources, more technology, electronic recording of hearings, and regular mediation first, then a possible next step of “child custody recommending counselors.” 

The world at ground zero looked mighty different from the world view from 30,000 feet in the policy and legislative arena. It was clearly important to have legal changes which could eventually impact cases. Without that, there would be no change.

We knew appeals could help and we needed laws to make appeals possible. We needed transcripts first. That continued to be the sticking place. We joined the Family Violence Appellate Project (FVAP) in calling for court reporters in all family court cases so they could appeal cases. 

How ridiculous to have hearings without a record. It made court procedures a sham. Judges could get away with anything. Oversight is everything.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.