Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 12: Gaining Momentum

“My attitude has always been, if you fall flat on your face, at least you’re moving forward. All you have to do is get back up and try again.”

Richard Branson

We tried to get the California Commission on the Status of Women interested again in the family court crisis but got nowhere.  The newly restructured Commission wanted nothing to do with us.

Meanwhile, in my mostly rural Yolo County with a population of about 220,000, the Board of Supervisors began an in depth look at our child welfare system and the 302 foster children in it. One supervisor, Max Rexroad, was the driving force.

He had been a foster parent and Judge Steven Basha had removed the child after five years, to reunify with his unsafe birth parents. It was also fueled by several child deaths in the county.  Over the years, referrals for child abuse and neglect had increased dramatically, to 2,304, although only slightly more than half were screened in and 460 were investigated.

The outcome was that improved relationships were built with mandated reporters such as teachers who had complained that nothing happened when they made reports.  The 2017 report said the Board was satisfied with the local child welfare services progress.

However, dependency court Judge Basha was still problematic. He had been Presiding Judge in Yolo County for three years until 2012 and was asked by the Chief Justice to serve on the Futures Commission in 2015. 

The Yolo County Board of Supervisors harnessed the judge by voting in April 2017 to reassign him from dependency court, and if that did not happen, the Board would formally object every time a new dependency matter came before him. They would disqualify him as prejudiced under Code of Civil Procedures section 170.6.

[T]he Board would formally object every time a new dependency matter came before him.

What a clever, bold solution.  Judge Basha mercifully retired on January 23, 2018.

A group of Yolo County agencies joined forces on a project to address the needs of victims of family violence, sexual assault and human trafficking as part of the new Family Violence Coordination Pilot Program, the next iteration of a countywide family justice center. Our local domestic violence center Empower Yolo led by Lynnette Irlmeier was already doing many of the coordinating activities and it seemed a natural hub.

Client navigators became a crucial piece in a centralized intake process. Cameron Handley from the Yolo County Attorney’s office, who had years before established the Multi-Disciplinary Interview Center, became the lead organizer. We breathed a huge sigh of relief.

Our District Attorney Jeff Reisig prosecuted two incest offenders. I wrote a special to the Davis Enterprise on May 7, 2017 commending him and urging the community to report child sex abuse to law enforcement. The very day the article ran, Scott Sorgent, a science teacher in Woodland was arrested, suspected of molesting a student.

Our local efforts were boosted by a “to whom it may concern” letter from Sarah Buel, Clinical Professor of Law at the Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law in Arizona on November 14, 2016 about Barry Goldstein’s book The Quincy Solution: Stop Domestic Violence and Save $500 Billion. She urged people to read the book.  She and District Attorney Bill Delahunt had worked together to develop a highly successful model in Quincy, Massachusetts, and she reiterated the best practices that led to reduced domestic violence homicides:

  • Strict enforcement of criminal laws, protection orders and probations rules.
  • Practices that made it easier for victims to leave.
  • A coordinated community response. 

On the state level, Senator Connie Leyva introduced SB 170 to allow children of age 10 to speak to the judge if they wished. She withdrew the bill even though we were sure the Judiciary Committee would be interested in bargaining the age up to 12, the age when California children are granted many other legal rights. We figured the cottage industry folks got to her, in an uproar about losing their fees by cutting out the unethical middlemen, along with their handsome incomes.

On December 11, 2016, Salon magazine published a long article titled Custody in crisis: How family courts nationwide put children in danger by Laurie Udesky and 100reporters. Kathleen Russell from Center for Judicial Excellence had been indefatigable, working with the reporter for months. The case was de-identified but could have been any case. They were all so similar it was eerie.

We could usually finish protective mothers’ sentences.

  • A child reports sexual abuse by the father.
  • The battered mother is blamed for alienating the child.
  • The court layers on expensive appointees until the mother runs out of money. 
  • The father gets custody. 

The lead story from a Tennessee case had a surprise ending. The mother went to the FBI after the child was placed with the father which led to a grand jury indictment of the father as his child’s rapist. It was a perfect turn around case. We were overjoyed that in the end things turned out well, but I wanted to scream. Why wasn’t the boy protected at the beginning? 

Center for Judicial Excellence continued to get media and to work on getting a Performance Audit of mediators and child custody recommending counselors in California family courts. Kathleen came up with the idea of asking the budget committee to have the Judicial Council use a portion of their discretionary funds for a Judicial Performance Evaluation pilot program in Northern California.

Many other states had JPEs which helped to weed out incompetent judges. The California Judicial Council did not like that idea. Why not? One would think they would want to identify incompetent judges, rather than live with the embarrassment of constant negative publicity.

One would think they would want to identify incompetent judges, rather than live with the embarrassment of constant negative publicity.

On January 17, 2017, ProPublica had an exceptionally long article titled Dysfunction Disorder: NYC paid millions for flawed mental health reports. Family court judges relied on them routinely. Parents and children lived with the consequences by Joaquin Sapien. Flawed mental health reports were used because the judges wanted cover.   “There can be a tendency to get somebody to opine, to get some protection from an expert.”

Although the article was focused on child welfare cases, the New York system had all the same problems we had in California with mental health professionals, plus the equally horrifying mounting death toll when judges got it tragically wrong.

The Sacramento News and Review ran a front page article the next week titled The Judge Took My Son Away: A father’s ordeal to reclaim his child reveals a family court system that places kids back in the hands of alleged abusers.   Journalist Alastair Bland highlighted Josie Cohen’s case, which was much more the norm in that the mother loses custody to the batterer or molester.  Somehow leading with a father’s case where the mother was the abuser seemed safer, even though mothers were the protective parents in nearly all the cases we knew about.  At least the media was picking up interest. This was no longer an issue we had to explain.

Kathleen’s media campaign was paying off.

In a media-worthy, almost comic move, the audit of the Commission on Judicial Performance, which Kathleen had spearheaded, hit a dramatic snag in the fall of 2016. The Commission sued the Bureau of State Audit, alleging the audit would intrude on their core functions, break confidentiality, and force them to pay the nearly $500,000. 

We protested to the Legislature that taxpayers were funding this lawsuit nonsense, and that we were paying for attorneys for both agencies, not to mention their time having to counteract a lawsuit. We argued that the audit should go forward.  It made for great press.

people standing in a circle pointing fingers

We wondered what the CJP was hiding and why they were stalling. Were they also shredding documents like the Marin County court did when they were audited?

In January 2017, the Twelfth Battered Mothers Custody Conference (BMCC) returned to the Albany New York area and was titled Reflect, Recharge and Regroup! There was a need for a moment to catch our collective breath.

Catherine Campbell became Executive Director of California Protective Parents Association in February 2017.  She had all the marketing skills to take the organization to the next level. We felt so fortunate. Karen had been our courageous Executive Director from the beginning, nearly two decades earlier, and was more than ready to turn over the reins.

Catherine’s newsletters were like Monet paintings compared to my black and white line drawing newsletters. I was so relieved to turn that task over to her.

In March, the mothers rallied from their reflection and went again to Congress to ask for co-sponsors for the Resolution. H Con Res 150 had been reintroduced.  Patrice Lenowitz from the Nurtured Parent explained the dangers of family court at TEDx Bergen Community College that month. 

In California that year, Senator Pan introduced SB 18 to have a Bill of Rights for Children. It died in committee. He introduced SB 426 and Assemblyman Arambula introduced AB 992 both for home visitation programs. Both died in committee, despite SB 1596 (Runner) which had established the Nurse-Family Partnership program in 2006. 

Home visits have been shown to reduce child abuse, yet AB 50 (Mullin) on home visitation had also been vetoed by the Governor in 2016. Why?

I sent two letters to the Sacramento Court Presiding Judge about concerns regarding twice publicly censured “Chainsaw” Peter McBrien being hired as a commissioner after he retired as a judge. The letter was bounced down to, of all people, his friend Supervising Judge Family Law James Mize who had hired McBrien in the first place. Judge Mize pretended he did not know me in his reply, saying he would look into the matter. 

On April 22, 2017, the Daily Republic in Solano County had an article on a demonstration by Mothers of Lost Children titled More than 2 dozen mothers protest Solano court’s custody stance. They were protesting the court’s domestic violence stance taken by four local judges who relied on parental alienation and endangered children.  They were working with the FBI.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.