Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 27: Safe Child Coalition

“Start where you are. Use what you have. Do what you can.”

Arthur Ashe

On April 4 there was another Elkins Task Force focus meeting in Los Angeles, only for local litigants, and a public Elkins Family Law Task Force meeting in San Francisco two days later. We knew that was window-dressing, since they had already launched AB 939 to ostensibly roll out the Task Force intentions.

We had an event in Sacramento on April 14, 2009, to introduce our new national lobbying group Safe Child Coalition. Our goal was to have a massive culture shift in the family court system to keep children safe. Steve Burdo became the Executive Director. We wanted:

  1. Oversight/Accountability
    • Develop State/Federal Grand Juries or citizen review boards.
    • Have a Federal Task Force.
    • Create a national database.
    • Find pro bono appellate attorneys.
    • Have videotaped hearings.
  2. Education
    • Develop an educational campaign.
    • Create a focus message to inform officials and the public of the person, societal and financial costs of family court failing to protect children.
  3. Legislation
    • Develop relationships with elected officials.
    • Lobby to eliminate the funding provided to only fathers at the federal level.
    • Create a national safe child act.
    • Disconnect child support from parenting time to eliminate financial incentives to reduce child support by gaining more parenting time. The more parents had time with the child, the less child support was allocated to them.
  4. Court appointees
    • File complaint against court appointed mental health professionals.
    • Remove immunity for appointed evaluators.
    • Eliminate evaluators.
    • Set standards for mental health professionals and minor’s counsel/Guardians ad Litem.
  5. Violence prevention
    • Implement Integrated Domestic/Family Violence courts.
    • Ensure risk/lethality assessments are used.
    • Have child abuse investigations conducted by multi-disciplinary child advocacy teams.
    • Have District Attorney’s office present facts/evidence on a standard report form.

Our action plan was equally as lofty.

  1. On the local county level, we would
    • Write letters to the editor and OpEds, create sample letters, engage social media and continue protests in front of family courthouses.
    • Meet with country Boards of Supervisors to request multidisciplinary interview child advocacy teams to provide evidence in violence/abuse cases.
    • Create a template for complaints against professionals.
    • Make complaints to County Grand Juries.
  2. On the state level, we would
    • Find legislators to author bills.
    • Write legislation to create a Domestic/Family Violence court using risk assessments and standard reporting forms.
    • Replace mental health professional with multidisciplinary teams.
    • Ensure child physical and sexual safety is the highest priority in custody decisions.
    • Have videotaping of all hearings.
    • Set standards and limits for court appointees.
    • Disconnect child support from parenting time.
    • Fund pro bono attorneys.
  3. On the national level, we would
    • Demonstrate and educate lawmakers in Washington DC twice a year.
    • Ask National Partnership to End Interpersonal Violence (NPEIV) to help us create a National Safe Child Act.
    • Meet with elected officials to request oversight hearings.
    • Request a Federal Grand Jury inquest and FBI public corruption/civil rights investigation into the cover up of child sex abuse by family courts.
    • Eliminate Fatherhood funding.
    • Create a national database to track cases of children place with abusers by family courts.
  4. On the International level, we would
    • Request assistance from Amnesty International.
    • Sent complaints to the United Nations Commission on the Status of Women.

It was a huge mountain to climb, pushing an equally huge boulder of denial and system failure at all levels which simply could not be by accident. I felt a bit exhausted just thinking about it.  But we couldn’t stop. There were too many tragedies happening.

One California case was especially horrifying.

In Santa Clara County, where Karen Winner first reported on California family court corruption in 1997, Alycia Mesiti-Allen and her brother had been placed in the custody of their father by Judge Vincent J. Chiarello in 2005. Their father had a criminal record including drunk driving, bank fraud, and domestic violence. Their mother was depressed. He had a lawyer. She did not. The court investigator and the judge decided the mother was unfit.  Alycia disappeared the next year when she was fourteen. Her father said she ran away, and soon after, he moved to Los Angeles. Convinced that Alycia had not run away, her mother and great-aunt Roberta Fitzpatrick kept the pressure on law enforcement.

Finally, in March 2009, cadaver-sniffing dogs found Alycia’s remains at her father’s former rental house in Ceres, CA. She had been murdered on August 13, 2006, after being drugged by her father. Police found thousands of child pornography images, including videos of him sexually assaulting an unconscious Alycia. He was operating a meth lab when he was arrested and later admitted to sexually assaulting other girls. In 2017, he was sentenced to life in prison.

Alycia Mesiti-Allen

If Santa Clara County Judge Chiarello and the court investigator had been unbiased, this teenager would be alive today. It was a completely preventable death. There is blood on the judge’s hands, yet he continues to serve as a Santa Clara County judge.

On the other side of the country on March 7, 2009 in Illinois, Amy Leichtenberg was ordered to send her sons Jack (7) and Duncan (9) with their abusive, unstable father Michael Connelly for an unsupervised weekend visit. The visits had previously been supervised. She had an order of protection due to his violence against her, which had been violated 57 times.  Amy had tried to warn the court, to no avail.

An Illinois officer threatened her if she didn’t give the boys to their father, she would be arrested for not complying with a judge’s order. That was the last time she ever saw them. Three weeks later, they were found dead. Jack had died from a stab wound and Duncan had died from drugging. Their father was also found dead, hanging from a nearby tree.  Amy filed a federal lawsuit in 2010 against the City of Leroy Police. They settled with her in 2013.

Amy Leichtenberg and her three children

Horrified, we kept going.

On April 1, we went to Judge Peter McBrien’s hearing by the Commission on Judicial Performance in San Francisco. He looked terrible. Judges James Mize, Thomas Cecil, Robert Hight and Appellate Justice Scotland testified for him. He later got off with a second public reprimand.

Nearly a week later, Elkins Family Law Task Force held an Advocate and Litigant hearing in San Francisco with 50 mothers and 4 fathers. One mother testified that her son had taped his special master telling him that if he kept reporting abuse, he’d be put in foster care and might be killed, because even his mom didn’t believe him. Two psychologists testified this was torture.

The Task Force members seemed to listen carefully. We were pretty sure it was a facade.

On April 14, California-based umbrella organization National Safe Child Coalition held a gala of 40-50 people at Fuzio’s Restaurant in Sacramento to announce its formation. Marivic Mabanag, President and CEO of our new organization, invited Jim Beall, Ted Lieu, Fiona Ma, Steve Knight, Hector de la Torre, Cameron Smyth who all spoke. Kathleen Russell and Steve Burdo from Center for Judicial Excellence brought the photo exhibit of mothers and children. Meera Fox from Child Abuse Solutions, Inc. hosted.  Marivic gave bamboo plants to mothers.

The momentum was great. We weren’t sure whether the new organization should be incorporated as a non-profit 501(c)(3) which provided tax write offs for donations or a 501(c)(4) which could do more lobbying. We held off filing for formal status.  That turned out to be a very big mistake.

Our Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau’s annual educational conferences in Davis continues. We survivors knew somebody needed to point out that children were being deliberately raped and murdered by parents and in deadly rituals.

The Fifteenth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness conference, co-sponsored by ISSB, CPPA and IVAT, began on April 24, 2009 at Sierra Health Foundation.  Transforming Treatment: Symptoms, Substances and Axis IV was again introduced by Steve Mayberg MD and Michael Cunningham. On the panel were Randy Noblitt PhD, EMDR therapist Susan Curry MFT, and Substance Abuse and Mental Health Administration (SAMHSA) representative Ann Jennings Ph.D. whose daughter Anna had tried to tell about her abuse but was instead labeled schizophrenic and eventually committed suicide.

They discussed evidence-based approaches to treatment for underlying trauma that would improve outcomes and recovery and lead to social and cost saving. We were trying to impact public mental health therapists to understand the origins of their clients’ symptoms. I wondered if it had any impact on their conditioning at all. I wondered if they realized the part they were playing in the coverup of child abuse.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.