“All primates subjected to early abuse and deprivation are vulnerable to engage in violent relationships with peers as adults. Males tend to be hyper-aggressive, and females fail to protect themselves and their offspring against danger.”
Bessel van der Kolk
The National Institute of Justice (NIJ) Practical Implications of Current Domestic Violence Research: for Law Enforcement, Prosecutors and Judges recommended numerous remedies.
REMEDIES
- Specialized domestic violence law enforcement units that followed up with victims and gathered evidence significantly increased the likelihood of prosecution/conviction/sentencing.
- Clear policy pronouncements from top administration are more likely to improve officer responses to domestic violence than general domestic violence training.
- Police department call takers do more extensive inquiries, by asking:
- If weapons are involved.
- Callers to stay on the line until police arrive.
- If children are present.
- Whether the suspect uses drugs/alcohol.
- Whether restraining orders are in effect.
- Whether the suspect is on probation or parole.
- Officers were more likely to amass evidence to turn over to prosecutors.
- They were more likely to help victims serve protective orders and assist in safety planning.
- Victims were more likely to leave abusers sooner/report re-abuse/secure protective order.
- Victims were satisfied by arrests of abusers/warrants against abusers/protective orders.
- Arrest, or a warrant for arrest if the accused fled the scene, deters re-abuse but is not enough (re-abuse was predicted by prior criminal history, pending warrant and if they fled the scene.)
- There were more prosecutions due to victim follow-up and improved police linkage.
- There was an enhanced likelihood of successful prosecution and increased victim safety.
- Reoffending was nearly half that of suspects that were not handled by these units.
- Specialized domestic violence prosecution units help, especially if adequately funded and associated with specialized domestic violence law enforcement units and courts.
- Increased domestic violence prosecutions and convictions.
- Increased victim cooperation and satisfaction.
- Victim testimony was the evidence most frequently relied upon by prosecutors.
- If dispositions were geared to reduce risk of re-abuse, that increased victim safety.
- Prosecutors worked with law enforcement to gather as much evidence as possible and accurately identify all potential witnesses and ways to contact them.
- Children may also be potential witnesses.
- Prosecutors can file additional charges for endangering the welfare of children.
- There was a higher likelihood of convictions with sentences of incarceration.
- Most cases were disposed of before trial, without removing incarceration.
- Aggressive domestic violence prosecution did not result in increased, sustained trials.
- Just prosecuting offenders does not deter further criminal abuse, as the majority of “high risk” arrested abusers will re-abuse regardless of prosecution.
- Significant sanctions and more intrusive sentences (e.g., incarceration, work release, electronic monitoring, specialized probation instead of only fines or suspended sentences without probation) significantly reduced rearrest.
- Domestic violence courts with specialized prosecutors help, with augmented conditions:
- Drug and alcohol abstinence and testing.
- Longer and more expensive batterer intervention programs (i.e., 52 weeks).
- More no-contact protective orders.
- Attendance at fatherhood programs or women’s groups for female offenders.
- More mental health evaluations.
- Mandatory employment.
- Restrictions on weapons.
- Specialized domestic violence courts that are user-friendly, safe environments for petitioners, sympathetic to parties and firm with abusers, associated with:
- Decreased reoffending and re-abuse.
- Victim safety and satisfaction.
- Offender accountability.
- Specialized intake and court staffing for domestic violence cases.
- Improved victim access.
- More efficient case flow and effective management of domestic violence cases.
- Coordination of the cases involving relevant parties.
- Integrating requisite information for the court.
- Increased convictions and decreased dismissals.
- Increased offender compliance by imposing court-ordered conditions and by increasing penalties for noncompliance.
- Expedited hearings.
- Assistance for victims by court staff, often assisted by related specialized, vertical domestic violence prosecution units (one prosecutor stays on case).
- Court processes to ensure victims’ safety (e.g., court metal detectors, separate waiting rooms, specialized orders and victim referrals).
- increased court monitoring.
- Enforcement of batterer compliance with court orders, often exercised by specialized probation supervision units.
- Consideration of children involved in domestic violence.
- Enhanced domestic violence training for judges.
- Judicial attention before trial to address risk to victims results in quicker case resolution and decrease re-abuse by defendants who fail to show for trial.
- Court dispositions tend to be more substantial and more rigorously enforced.
- What does not work?
- Arrest and protective orders alone do not assure victim safety and judges should advise victims of protective order limitations.
- Victims with civil restraining orders or criminal no contact orders are just as likely to be re-abused as those who drop the orders.
- Victims seeking civil remedies for abuse are at the same level of risk for re-abuse as victims of abusers who were arrested for abusing them.
- There is no evidence that anger management programs or couples counseling effectively prevent batterers from re-abusing or committing new offenses.
- There is no difference in rearrest rates for those who completed anger management programs and those who failed to complete one.
- Those who completed anger management programs recidivated at higher rates than those who completed batterer intervention programs.
- Abusers who relied on anger management control techniques were more likely to re-abuse their partners than those who relied on programs that increased empathy, redefined their manhood, and encouraged more cooperative decision-making as a means to ending their abuse.
- Batterer programs alone are not likely to protect most victims or intimate partners and need to be supplemented by other measures to assure victim safety.
- Unless batterer programs are closely monitored and program compliance is rigorously enforced, batterer intervention programs may be ineffective and give false hope.
- Prosecutors should be reluctant to recommend court-ordered conditions including batterer intervention programs without close monitoring and enforcement.
- What does work to reduce risk of re-abuse?
- Permanent protective orders deter physical abuse, especially when all contact is barred (women victims who did not obtain orders were at higher risk for re-abuse, and had more substance abuse, more assaults/injuries, and were not married to their abuser).
- Enhanced sentencing of abusers involving probation with relevant conditions (e.g., lengthy batterer programs, abstinence, no-contact orders) with enhanced monitoring and specialized supervision of abusers help reduce re-abuse.
- Those who completed a certified batterer intervention program were significantly less likely to be re-arraigned for any offense, a violent offense or a protection order violation.
- Despite lackluster effects, longer batterer programs may be better. (In California the program must be conducted for two hours each week for a minimum of 52 consecutive weeks, pursuant to Penal Code §1203.097(A)(6)).
- Incorporating alcohol and/or drug treatment as a standard component of batterer intervention programs adds to the likelihood of reductions in re-abuse among batterers.
- Effective treatment should include abstinence testing to assure abstinence.
- Specialized probation supervision caseloads
- Compliance with mandated batterer intervention programs provides prosecutors and judges with a dynamic risk instrument based on a defendant’s ongoing current behavior.
- Noncompliance at the first court monitoring predicted program failure and recidivism.
- Lower domestic violence arrests were obtained primarily through early detection and incarceration of probationers who either re-abuse or failed to comply.
- Re-abuse can be prevented if prosecutors and courts respond expeditiously to batterers who fail to attend or to comply with court-referred batterer intervention programs and respond to noncompliant abusers immediately to safeguard victims.
- More probation revocations for noncompliance showed significantly less re-abuse, thus prosecutors and courts should respond immediately to an abuser’s first failure to enroll in or attend a court-mandated batterer intervention program.
- Specialized caseloads had significantly less re-abuse with lower risk probationers (i.e., those without prior arrest histories); therefore, increased surveillance may reduce risk of re-abuse for these abusers.
- Criminal history is the strongest most consistent predictor of noncompletion and new arrest, along with offender and substance abuse.
- Higher risk abusers are younger, have less education, greater criminal histories and violence in family of origin, less often employed and less motivated to change, along with substance abuse.
- Abusers are significantly more likely to be arrested for protective order violations than other common domestic violence offenses.
- Post-dispositional compliance hearings are important, as well as supervised probation.
- Incarcerate any offenders who re-abuses while enrolled in or after batterer programs (just re-enrolling high-risk abusers in these programs endangers victims).
- For noncompliant abusers, incarceration assures immediate victim protection.
- Noncompliant probationers may need to attend weekly compliance court sessions until they complete the program.
The National Institute of Justice was spot on.