Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 29: Research and Protocol

“All primates subjected to early abuse and deprivation are vulnerable to engage in violent relationships with peers as adults. Males tend to be hyper-aggressive, and females fail to protect themselves and their offspring against danger.”

Bessel van der Kolk

The National Institute of Justice (NIJ) Practical Implications of Current Domestic Violence Research: for Law Enforcement, Prosecutors and Judges recommended numerous remedies.

REMEDIES

  1. Specialized domestic violence law enforcement units that followed up with victims and gathered evidence significantly increased the likelihood of prosecution/conviction/sentencing.
    • Clear policy pronouncements from top administration are more likely to improve officer responses to domestic violence than general domestic violence training.
    • Police department call takers do more extensive inquiries, by asking:
      • If weapons are involved.
      • Callers to stay on the line until police arrive.
      • If children are present.
      • Whether the suspect uses drugs/alcohol.
      • Whether restraining orders are in effect.
      • Whether the suspect is on probation or parole.
    • Officers were more likely to amass evidence to turn over to prosecutors.
    • They were more likely to help victims serve protective orders and assist in safety planning.
    • Victims were more likely to leave abusers sooner/report re-abuse/secure protective order.
    • Victims were satisfied by arrests of abusers/warrants against abusers/protective orders.
    • Arrest, or a warrant for arrest if the accused fled the scene, deters re-abuse but is not enough (re-abuse was predicted by prior criminal history, pending warrant and if they fled the scene.)
    • There were more prosecutions due to victim follow-up and improved police linkage.
    • There was an enhanced likelihood of successful prosecution and increased victim safety.
    • Reoffending was nearly half that of suspects that were not handled by these units.
  2. Specialized domestic violence prosecution units help, especially if adequately funded and associated with specialized domestic violence law enforcement units and courts.
    • Increased domestic violence prosecutions and convictions.
    • Increased victim cooperation and satisfaction.
    • Victim testimony was the evidence most frequently relied upon by prosecutors.
    • If dispositions were geared to reduce risk of re-abuse, that increased victim safety.
    • Prosecutors worked with law enforcement to gather as much evidence as possible and accurately identify all potential witnesses and ways to contact them.
    • Children may also be potential witnesses.
    • Prosecutors can file additional charges for endangering the welfare of children.
    • There was a higher likelihood of convictions with sentences of incarceration.
    • Most cases were disposed of before trial, without removing incarceration.
    • Aggressive domestic violence prosecution did not result in increased, sustained trials.
    • Just prosecuting offenders does not deter further criminal abuse, as the majority of “high risk” arrested abusers will re-abuse regardless of prosecution.
    • Significant sanctions and more intrusive sentences (e.g., incarceration, work release, electronic monitoring, specialized probation instead of only fines or suspended sentences without probation) significantly reduced rearrest.
  3. Domestic violence courts with specialized prosecutors help, with augmented conditions:
    • Drug and alcohol abstinence and testing.
    • Longer and more expensive batterer intervention programs (i.e., 52 weeks).
    • More no-contact protective orders.
    • Attendance at fatherhood programs or women’s groups for female offenders.
    • More mental health evaluations.
    • Mandatory employment.
    • Restrictions on weapons.
  4. Specialized domestic violence courts that are user-friendly, safe environments for petitioners, sympathetic to parties and firm with abusers, associated with:
    • Decreased reoffending and re-abuse.
    • Victim safety and satisfaction.
    • Offender accountability.
    • Specialized intake and court staffing for domestic violence cases.
    • Improved victim access.
    • More efficient case flow and effective management of domestic violence cases.
    • Coordination of the cases involving relevant parties.
    • Integrating requisite information for the court.
    • Increased convictions and decreased dismissals.
    • Increased offender compliance by imposing court-ordered conditions and by increasing penalties for noncompliance.
    • Expedited hearings.
    • Assistance for victims by court staff, often assisted by related specialized, vertical domestic violence prosecution units (one prosecutor stays on case).
    • Court processes to ensure victims’ safety (e.g., court metal detectors, separate waiting rooms, specialized orders and victim referrals).
    • increased court monitoring.
    • Enforcement of batterer compliance with court orders, often exercised by specialized probation supervision units.
    • Consideration of children involved in domestic violence.
    • Enhanced domestic violence training for judges.
    • Judicial attention before trial to address risk to victims results in quicker case resolution and decrease re-abuse by defendants who fail to show for trial.
    • Court dispositions tend to be more substantial and more rigorously enforced.
  5. What does not work?
    • Arrest and protective orders alone do not assure victim safety and judges should advise victims of protective order limitations.
    • Victims with civil restraining orders or criminal no contact orders are just as likely to be re-abused as those who drop the orders.
    • Victims seeking civil remedies for abuse are at the same level of risk for re-abuse as victims of abusers who were arrested for abusing them.
    • There is no evidence that anger management programs or couples counseling effectively prevent batterers from re-abusing or committing new offenses.
    • There is no difference in rearrest rates for those who completed anger management programs and those who failed to complete one.
    • Those who completed anger management programs recidivated at higher rates than those who completed batterer intervention programs.
    • Abusers who relied on anger management control techniques were more likely to re-abuse their partners than those who relied on programs that increased empathy, redefined their manhood, and encouraged more cooperative decision-making as a means to ending their abuse.
    • Batterer programs alone are not likely to protect most victims or intimate partners and need to be supplemented by other measures to assure victim safety.
    • Unless batterer programs are closely monitored and program compliance is rigorously enforced, batterer intervention programs may be ineffective and give false hope.
    • Prosecutors should be reluctant to recommend court-ordered conditions including batterer intervention programs without close monitoring and enforcement.
  6. What does work to reduce risk of re-abuse?
    • Permanent protective orders deter physical abuse, especially when all contact is barred (women victims who did not obtain orders were at higher risk for re-abuse, and had more substance abuse, more assaults/injuries, and were not married to their abuser).
    • Enhanced sentencing of abusers involving probation with relevant conditions (e.g., lengthy batterer programs, abstinence, no-contact orders) with enhanced monitoring and specialized supervision of abusers help reduce re-abuse.
    • Those who completed a certified batterer intervention program were significantly less likely to be re-arraigned for any offense, a violent offense or a protection order violation.
    • Despite lackluster effects, longer batterer programs may be better.  (In California the program must be conducted for two hours each week for a minimum of 52 consecutive weeks, pursuant to Penal Code §1203.097(A)(6)).
    • Incorporating alcohol and/or drug treatment as a standard component of batterer intervention programs adds to the likelihood of reductions in re-abuse among batterers.
    • Effective treatment should include abstinence testing to assure abstinence.
  7. Specialized probation supervision caseloads
    • Compliance with mandated batterer intervention programs provides prosecutors and judges with a dynamic risk instrument based on a defendant’s ongoing current behavior.
    • Noncompliance at the first court monitoring predicted program failure and recidivism.
    • Lower domestic violence arrests were obtained primarily through early detection and incarceration of probationers who either re-abuse or failed to comply.
    • Re-abuse can be prevented if prosecutors and courts respond expeditiously to batterers who fail to attend or to comply with court-referred batterer intervention programs and respond to noncompliant abusers immediately to safeguard victims.
    • More probation revocations for noncompliance showed significantly less re-abuse, thus prosecutors and courts should respond immediately to an abuser’s first failure to enroll in or attend a court-mandated batterer intervention program. 
    • Specialized caseloads had significantly less re-abuse with lower risk probationers (i.e., those without prior arrest histories); therefore, increased surveillance may reduce risk of re-abuse for these abusers.
    • Criminal history is the strongest most consistent predictor of noncompletion and new arrest, along with offender and substance abuse.
    • Higher risk abusers are younger, have less education, greater criminal histories and violence in family of origin, less often employed and less motivated to change, along with substance abuse.
    • Abusers are significantly more likely to be arrested for protective order violations than other common domestic violence offenses.
    • Post-dispositional compliance hearings are important, as well as supervised probation.
    • Incarcerate any offenders who re-abuses while enrolled in or after batterer programs (just re-enrolling high-risk abusers in these programs endangers victims).
    • For noncompliant abusers, incarceration assures immediate victim protection.
    • Noncompliant probationers may need to attend weekly compliance court sessions until they complete the program.

The National Institute of Justice was spot on.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.