“It takes a village to raise a child. It takes a village to abuse one.”
Mitchell Garabedian in Spotlight
On the federal level, The Office of Violence Against Women planned a focus group to work on the problem. Lynn Rosenthal, the former Executive Director of the National Network to End Domestic Violence, was appointed the White House Advisor on Violence Against Women.

The new US Attorney General Eric Holder publicly posed the issue at the National Summit on the Intersection of Domestic Violence and Child Maltreatment of battered women losing custody. On June 28, 2009, he asked the rhetorical question, “Why are mothers who are the victims of domestic violence losing custody of their children to the courts or child protective services?” We wondered too.

Irene Weiser and Stop Family Violence held an email campaign focused on California lawmakers and justice officials asking for help for Cindy Dumas and her sons and announcing a protest in San Diego. Cindy had fled with her children. The District Attorney told her family that she could safely return, rather than be prosecuted. When she did, the family court was waiting. Her abused son Damon fled on his own instead of going to live with his father, who he maintained had sexually abused him.
Karen and I went to the IVAT conference in San Diego in September and participated in the National Partnership to End Interpersonal Violence Across the Lifespan (NPEIV) Think Tank. Conference coordinator Bob Geffner and his colleagues had gathered 85 organizations to join NPEIV. I spoke as a survivor on a panel organized by Susan Omelian from My Avenging Angels.
So much was happening it made our heads spin.
But still, children were being removed in droves from their safe mothers and allowed to visit or placed at great risk with violent, incestuous fathers. The murders of children of divorce began piling up. The Center for Judicial Excellence had begun keeping count in 2008.
In retrospect, Karen and I had taken a wild leap of faith. We had zero idea what we were doing. We were both still working day jobs and were searching for the lever that would make this human rights crisis turn around. Having allies like Kathleen and Marivic with the knowledge we lacked was crucial.
Mothers contacted us every day from all over the country, and other countries too. Most had already left their abusers and were in the midst of the deadly medieval circus, being fed to the lions.

We were helpless except to explain that they were not the crazy ones. High price psychologists calling them crazy, delusional, or schizophrenic, were in fact off their rockers. I continued to view them like the cold-blooded doctors described by Robert Jay Lifton in his gripping 1986 book The Nazi Doctors. A generation of children were being psychologically and often physically destroyed by being placed in homes that were worse than prisoner of war camps.
Was I being too dramatic? Maybe. But neither the Nazi physicians nor the Family Court psychologists had a shred of compassion for the helpless mothers and children they encountered.
Some mothers were walking a tightrope. Was it safer to stay and take the blows for the child, while running the risk of CPS swooping in to remove the child? Or was it safer to leave and run the risk of provoking a custody dispute so the enraged fathers could make good on their promise to get custody?
Most mothers were only vaguely aware of this gamble. Each believed it could never happen to them. Not in their case. Not with their child. Then it did. We, along with advocates and attorneys, tried to warn them early. It was mostly unsuccessful.
“But I’m a soccer mom.”
“He never had anything to do with the kids when we were together.”
“He’s an alcoholic. I never touch the stuff.”
“Not in my case. Not my child.”
And then it was.
We felt like canaries in mineshafts, keeling over from early exposure to, our voices muted, in shock. Or cursed seers like the mythical prophet Cassandra, who could only warn, be ignored and watch the painful fallout.
In September, Karen and I went to the IVAT Think Tank, where attorney Nancy Erickson and Renee Beeker presented on custody evaluators and cost. Kathleen Faller, Colin Ross, Wendy Murphy wanted action. We met with Cindy Dumas and 15 other mothers.
We went again to the Elkins Family Law Task Force meeting in Los Angeles on October 27, even knowing that the recommendations had already been submitted and the fix was in. Helen Lynn’s teenage grandson Mac testified.
The Chair of the Task Force Justice Laurie Zelon had a concern. “Wouldn’t it be scary to meet directly with the judge?” Mac rocked back in his chair and looked at her for a long moment. “Well,” he said, and paused. Then with perfect comedic timing, he drawled, “Not half as scary as living with a pedophile for 13 years.”
Mac rocked back in his chair and looked at her for a long moment. “Well,” he said, and paused. Then with perfect comedic timing, he drawled, “Not half as scary as living with a pedophile for 13 years.”
Mac and his younger sister Lynn had spoken out at one of our previous conferences. Lynn was so short at the time that her chin barely rested on the podium. Later, when they were still not rescued by the court, they ran away from their rapist father. When they were caught, their mother was sentenced to 12 years in prison. We heard that only the intervention of attorney Toby Kleinman and a call from Chris Cuomo’s investigative team led to her early release. It seemed the Chicago criminal justice system did not want too much scrutiny.
Mac finally came back to his grandparents in time to tell the Elkins Family Law Task Force what children need. A voice. A direct voice to the judge. Someone at Judicial Council said they referred to Mac’s potent testimony for years afterwards.
The Center for Judicial Excellence gave us a lovely award. We had excellent media thanks to Kathleen Russell who was a media expert. It was incredibly helpful. In October 2009, The I-Team reported on corruption of the huge family court financial cottage industry in their expose High Costs of Family Court: Parents Say They Are Drained Of Money By Court Professionals.
